Brief Background of the Case
Statement to Supporters
Click Here>>Singing for Liberty
USA vs Al-Arian
National Liberty Fund (NLF)


You Can Donate to Dr. Al-Arian’s Legal Defense Online Through PayPal or Credit Card.

(Note: Donations not tax-deductible ) If you don't have a PayPal account Click Sign Up

Frontpage Slideshow (version 2.0.0) - Copyright © 2006-2008 by JoomlaWorks


A Prosecutor Is Called 'Relentless'

The New York Sun

July 28, 2008

by: Josh Gerstein

A federal prosecutor who has led a series of investigations into Islamic militants and Muslim groups based in Virginia, Gordon Kromberg, may soon be facing a trial of sorts himself, if defense lawyers get their way.

Attorneys for a former Florida college professor who pleaded guilty two years ago to aiding Palestinian Islamic Jihad, Sami Al-Arian, are asking a federal judge to hold a hearing on whether anti-Muslim bias led to the government's decision to obtain a new indictment of Al-Arian in June for contempt for refusing to testify before grand juries pursuing the Virginia organizations.

While the motion claims Muslim terrorism suspects are generally treated unfairly by the Justice Department, Al-Arian's lawyers argue that Mr. Kromberg, 51, has a particularly egregious record of intemperate statements and actions in a series of terrorism-related cases and investigations.

"Defense attorneys have objected for years that Mr. Kromberg, the lead counsel in many of these cases, has been using the Eastern District of Virginia to mete out his own brand of justice for Muslim terrorism subjects, often openly displaying his personal animus," Al-Arian's lead counsel, Jonathan Turley, wrote. "This long and controversial record forms the backdrop for the allegation of selective and malicious prosecution in this case."

Al-Arian's lawyers claim that in 2006, when Mr. Kromberg moved to obtain new testimony from the former professor following his guilty plea in Florida, the prosecutor "became agitated" in response to a defense lawyer's request that the testimony be put off until after the Muslim holy month of Ramadan. "They can kill each other during Ramadan. They can appear before the grand jury; all they can't do is eat before sunset," Mr. Kromberg responded, according to a declaration written by one of Al-Arian's attorneys, Jack Fernandez. Mr. Fernandez said the prosecutor described the request for a postponement as "all part of the attempted Islamization of the American justice system." Mr. Fernandez wrote that he viewed the comments as exhibiting "apparent bias against Muslims."

Mr. Fernandez also said Mr. Kromberg called the 57-month prison sentence Al-Arian received "a bonanza" for the Palestinian Arab activist. He had faced the potential of life in prison for acting as the leader of Palestinian Islamic Jihad in America, but a trial in 2005 resulted in his acquittal on eight counts and a mistrial on nine others where jurors could not reach a verdict. Al-Arian's lawyers contend that the dogged pursuit of their client is retribution for the outcome of the Tampa trial, which was widely seen as a failure for the government.

The new motion also asserts that Mr. Kromberg joked about the torture of a Virginia man then being held in Saudi Arabia, Ahmed Abu Ali. The suspect's lawyer, Salim Ali, said that when he asked Mr. Kromberg about the possibility of returning the young man to America, the prosecutor "smirked and stated that 'he's no good for us here, he has no fingernails left.'"

In a court declaration, Mr. Kromberg said that he had no recollection of making the statement and that he was arguing an appeal in another city when the comment was allegedly made.

Al-Arian's lawyers are also pointing to the arguments Mr. Kromberg made in the trial of a Virginia cancer researcher and Muslim preacher, Ali al-Timimi, who was accused of exhorting others to wage war against America by joining the Taliban. In the case, Mr. Kromberg argued that the religious beliefs of the defendant and other witnesses made it acceptable to lie to kaffirs, or nonbelievers in Islam. "If you are a kaffir, Timimi believes in time of war, he's supposed to lie to you," the prosecutor told jurors. Al-Timimi was convicted of treason and sentenced to life in prison.

"Kromberg argued to the jury that Timimi and the other Muslim witnesses — their testimony should be disregarded just on the basis of their religion," al-Timimi's defense lawyer, Edward MacMahon Jr., said. "I think it's an outrageous thing to argue in the courtroom. Imagine that directed at any other religion."

Mr. Kromberg declined to be interviewed for this article and said a written response to Al-Arian's motion would be filed in due course. In response to questions from The New York Sun, the U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia, Charles "Chuck" Rosenberg, issued a written statement denying any bias and standing behind Mr. Kromberg's work.

"Gordon Kromberg is a dedicated, talented, and scrupulously fair prosecutor," Mr. Rosenberg said. "Further, when we decide to prosecute an individual, that decision is based strictly on the facts and the law, and in the pursuit of justice, period."

A lawyer and former federal prosecutor who has squared off with Mr. Kromberg in court, Henry FitzGerald, said the prosecutor has acquired a reputation for leaving no stone unturned in cases relating to terrorism or funding for Islamic militant groups.

"Kromberg is absolutely relentless in his pursuit of everything that could be pursued in the way of forfeiture or prosecutions in this area. He's just indefatigable, relentless, tireless," Mr. FitzGerald said. "If you say he's doing the country's work to fight terrorism, that's good, he's a good fighter, but a lot of people say it's overkill, he doesn't listen to reasonable arguments. Everything is black until somebody takes him to court to prove it's white."

Mr. FitzGerald said Mr. Kromberg, while unusually persistent, does not take quixotic stances. "Kromberg's not a dumb man. He's smart. He's not going to go out and take an utterly groundless case, raise hell with it, and get himself in trouble. He just goes straight ahead, doesn't look left or right and pushes to the absolute limit," Mr. FitzGerald said.

Mr. Kromberg sought Al-Arian's testimony as part of an investigation into the finances of a Herndon, Va.- based think tank, the International Institute of Islamic Thought. In 2002, federal authorities executed search warrants at IIIT's headquarters and more than a dozen other locations, including residences of the organization's officers. Court papers said prosecutors had evidence of financial transfers involving the think tank, nonprofit groups, including some run by Al-Arian, and terrorist movements abroad, such as Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

A lawyer for IIIT, Nancy Luque, did not respond to repeated requests for an interview for this article. However, in 2006, she complained to the Washington Post that prosecutors had nothing to show for their raids. "You storm into people's homes, take their children's toys, terrorize the women, and 4 1/2 years later, you haven't got a scintilla of evidence against them," she told the Post.

A former federal terrorism prosecutor, Andrew McCarthy, said complaints that the Virginia probe is moving too slowly are silly coming from Al-Arian and others who have refused to cooperate. Several witnesses affiliated with IIIT have filed legal challenges to grand jury subpoenas and have pursued appeals to the 4th Circuit, resulting in lengthy delays. "I'm always amused when people who have obstructed an investigation for years, at the conclusion of years say, 'Years have gone by and nothing has been revealed,'" Mr. McCarthy said.

Justice Department officials also reject the notion that the IIIT probe, which grew out of an effort dubbed Operation Green Quest, has yielded nothing. They note the arrest and subsequent guilty plea of Abdurahman Alamoudi, a former Muslim-American political leader and founder of the American Muslim Council, who admitted in 2004 to involvement in a Libyan plot to assassinate Crown Prince Abdullah of Saudi Arabia. Alamoudi, whose home was among those searched in 2002 and who worked for a group related to IIIT, the Saar Foundation, was sentenced to 23 years in prison. In addition, a financier with ties to Saar who left America just after the 2002 raids, Soliman Biheiri, got 13 months in prison for immigration fraud and lying to customs agents.

Still, it is true that the principals in IIIT and the organization itself have not been charged, more than six and a half years after the investigation began.

Mr. McCarthy said Mr. Kromberg's statements about Islam seemed directed not to ordinary followers but to the beliefs of certain radical Islamic extremists. "If he's got an innate feeling of disapproval and hostility to that, I don't see the slightest problem with that. I do too, and so do most Americans," the ex-prosecutor said. "If he's concerned about the Islamization of our legal process or the idea that we should be recognizing certain tenets of Islamic law as we conduct law enforcement... Gordon is not the only prosecutor ever to have taken that position."

Al-Arian's motion includes no claim that Mr. Kromberg's alleged anti-Muslim animus is related to him being Jewish or to a pro-Israel bias. However, the Atlantic magazine and a left-leaning news agency, Inter Press Service, have called attention to a travelogue Mr. Kromberg wrote after traveling on a United Jewish Communities mission to Israel in 2002.

In the diary, Mr. Kromberg complained that Israel is losing the global public relations battle because of "a lack of resources on the Israeli side to provide information to the innumerable members of the press who are fed lies by the Palestinians ('hundreds were massacred in Jenin')."

"Bibi Netanyahu can only be in so many places at one time to answer so many questions," the prosecutor lamented.

Mr. Kromberg's journal also refers to the West Bank as "Judea and Samaria," which Inter Press described as "a term favored by right-wing Israelis."

As a whole, the diary exhibits a hostility toward Palestinian terrorism and a strong affinity for Israel, but gives no indication Mr. Kromberg is particularly religious. He wrote that he does not speak Hebrew and that his tour group opted to go shopping rather than visit Jerusalem's Western Wall.

Many Muslim activists consider Mr. Kromberg to be a doppelganger of a journalist and author of books warning about the threat posed by Muslim radicals in America, Steven Emerson. The selective prosecution motion asks for a hearing to explore why the prosecutor's statements "appear to track writings" by Mr. Emerson.

In an interview with the Sun, Mr. Emerson called the motion's claims about him and Mr. Kromberg "baseless."

Mr. Kromberg grew up in the village of Lawrence in Nassau County, just east of Queens. He volunteered briefly at an Israeli kibbutz and went to college at Princeton University, where he took part in the Reserve Officer Training Corps. The future prosecutor attended New York University Law School, where he graduated in 1982.

In the 1980s, Mr. Kromberg spent several years in South Korea as a military defense attorney in the Army's Judge Advocate General Corps, before taking a job in the Justice Department's civil division in 1987. He is still in the Army Reserve, where he holds the rank of Lieutenant Colonel.

In 2000, Mr. Kromberg briefly joined the staff of the independent counsel investigating President Clinton, Robert Ray. At the time, the impeachment trial was long over and Mr. Ray was considering whether to bring criminal charges against Mr. Clinton. They were never filed.

That year, Mr. Kromberg started work at the U.S. Attorney's Office in Northern Virginia, where he became a specialist in seizing money, cars, boats, and houses allegedly used in drug dealing and other crimes. Defense lawyers, civil libertarians, and some conservatives criticized the tactic as an end run around the government's obligation to prove criminals guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. As that criticism mounted, Mr. Kromberg became a point person in the Justice Department's effort to fend off legislation which would have made it tougher for the government to confiscate such property.

Some of the ire directed at Mr. Kromberg by the Muslim community stems from his vigorous prosecution of the so-called Paintball Eleven, a group of Muslims accused of training in Virginia to fight with a Pakistani militant group, Lashkar e-Taiba, against Indian forces in Kashmir. Nine of the eleven men were convicted at trial or pled guilty. Two were acquitted.

Mr. Kromberg later called one of the acquitted men, Sabri Benkahla, before grand juries and questioned him about his attendance and activities at jihad training camps in Afghanistan or Pakistan. Convinced that Benkahla's answers were false, the prosecutor obtained an indictment of Benkahla for obstruction of justice and making false statements to the FBI and the grand juries.

As with Al-Arian, defense lawyers for Benkahla said the perjury charges amounted to an effort by Mr. Kromberg to retry the earlier case in which Benkahla was acquitted.

"When you look at the prosecutions together, there is a pattern that really doesn't make Mr. Kromberg look very good," a Muslim scholar from Maryland who has been subpoenaed in the IIIT probe, Imad-ad-Dean Ahmad, said. "It reminds me of the Red Scare. Communism was a serious problem for America, but some people seemed to think almost every liberal was a Communist. Mr. Kromberg and a handful of other people in the government seem to have the same approach when it comes to outspoken Muslims."

Mr. Ahmad said the punishments for those convicted in the Paintball or, as the government prefers, Virginia Jihad, cases, were too extreme for individuals who planned no act of violence in America. "It's hard to imagine there isn't someone in the Department of Justice saying, 'Why are we doing this?'" he said.

Even Mr. Kromberg's critics acknowledge that he has a strong record of prevailing in court. Last month, a three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit unanimously upheld Benkahla's convictions and rejected the arguments that he was unconstitutionally put on trial twice for the same crime. "The investigations in which Benkahla was interviewed and the questions he was asked show no sign of having been manufactured for the sake of a second prosecution," Judge James Wilkinson III wrote. The court also upheld a 10-year prison sentence for Benkahla.

However, there are new signs that some judges have begun to chafe at Mr. Kromberg's aggressiveness.

Late last year, Judge Gerald Lee, who ordered Al-Arian jailed for a year on civil contempt, raised questions about the strategy pursued against the former professor. "Judge Lee expressed his frustration with the government's continued attempt to use contempt measures against Dr. Al-Arian and stated that he did not view these proceedings as a good use of the time and resources of either the government or the Court," Mr. Turley wrote to Mr. Kromberg, describing a court hearing in December. The e-mail was attached to a defense pleading filed recently in the criminal case. The defense attorney also wrote that the judge had urged Mr. Kromberg to ask Attorney General Mukasey, who had just been sworn in, for a "new review of the case."

Precisely what Judge Lee, Mr. Kromberg, or Mr. Turley said at the hearing is not publicly known because the judge refused this reporter's request for public access to the proceedings. A legal challenge to the secrecy is pending before the 4th Circuit.

At a bail hearing for Al-Arian earlier this month, Judge Leonie Brinkema sounded skeptical about the new contempt charges against him. "There's some strange signals coming out of this case," she said, according to the Associated Press. "I expect the Department of Justice to live up to its agreements." She granted bail to Al-Arian, but he remains in jail on orders from immigration authorities.

Still, Al-Arian may not get far with his argument that Mr. Kromberg used religion to win a tainted conviction against al-Timimi. Judge Brinkema, who will have to rule on the selective prosecution motion, presided over al-Timimi's trial and rejected defense motions that Mr. Kromberg's comments improperly invoked the defendant's religion.

The frustration and anger Mr. Kromberg provokes in some quarters may stem from an irreverence he sometimes displays in his dealings with defense attorneys and the courts.

In his declaration about Abu Ali, the terrorism suspect who claimed torture in Saudi Arabia, the prosecutor deadpanned, "I do not have any other information that would lead me to believe that he has anything wrong with his fingernails."

When Mr. Turley told Mr. Kromberg that "many" viewed the effort to force Al-Arian before a grand jury as a "transparent perjury trap," the prosecutor shot back an e-mail pointing out that a federal judge in Tampa found that Al-Arian lied to his neighbors for years by denying involvement with Palestinian Islamic Jihad. To underscore his point, Mr. Kromberg invoked a legendary British rock band.

"I hope that the next time that your client tries to convince the 'many' to whom you refer that he is something that he is not, that 'many' will remember the slogan of the Who, and loudly sing out together, 'We won't get fooled [by your client] again!'" the prosecutor wrote.

Link:Click here


Page 3 of 3

Trailer: USA vs Al-Arian

Video & Audio Releases

-Interview of Dr. Al-Arian in Anti-war Rally

Interview in anti-Iraq war rally in Washington, DC, Oct. 26, 2002

- Coalition Building Seminar by Dr. Al-Arian

Coalition Building Seminar for activists in Oct. 2002, in Ann Arbor, MI

-Democracy Now Exclusive Interview of Dr. Al-Arian

Democracy Now Exclusive and First Broaadcast Interview with Dr. Al-Arian since his 2003 arrest, February 7, 2007 -------------Click Video or Audio Stream

- Statement by Dr. Al-Arian's Daughter during Hungerstrike

Statement by Laila Al-Arian during hungerstrike, April 15,  2008

- Malcolm X Center Press Conference On Dr. Al-Arian

Former Attorney General Ramsey Clark, Malcolm X daughter, Civil Rights Leaders and Activists, NY, April 15,  2008

-Democracy Now Coverage of Dr. Al-Arian's Release

Democracy Now: Sami Al-Arian is released, Sept. 3, 2008

-Peace and Justice Foundation Rally for Justice

Statement by Ali Al-Arian, July 3, 2009

- Poem by Dr. Al-Arian: Innocent

- Singing for Liberty (Song and Slideshow)

- A Heart Full of Peace (Song about Dr. Al-Arian)

- Just Me, A Hit Song by the Band: Outlandish

-Link TV: USA vs Al-Arian

Documents & Releases

Statement of Chairs of American Muslim Task-Force on Civil Rights and Elections  (AMT) and  Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR)

Howard Zinn Statement on Professor Al-Arian



March 2000

December 2005alarian.jpg

January 2009

To be patriotic is to be able to question government policy in times of crisis.
To be patriotic is to stand up for the Bill of Rights and the Constitution in times of uncertainty and insecurity.
To be patriotic is to  speak up against the powerful in defense of the weak and the voiceless.
To be patriotic is to be willing to pay the price to preserve our freedoms, dignity, and rights.
To be patriotic is to
challenge the abuses of the PATRIOT Act.
From a speech by Dr. Al-Arian


UFF Summary: Al-Arian and USF


Announcement of Book: The Al-Arian Reader

A new compilation of all relevant articles to be released soon by the National Liberty Fund

Selected Poems
by Sami Al-Arian

We Shall Rise

To Maya Angelou
Like the dream of the slave
You rise
And with the scream of the brave
I shall rise
In honoring the memory of your ancestors
You rise
With my stateless brothers and sisters
I shall rise
Like dust in the sunlight
You rise
And as ashes in a fiery night
I shall rise
You offend
Because of your existence
And I
For my resistance
You upset them
Recalling their past
And I
By holding steadfast
They may trod you in dirt
May cause me all the hurt
Inflict upon you excruciating pain
While they shut me up and detain
But they won't see you broken
Neither would my faith be forsaken
As you've never bowed your head
And never lowered your eyes
I'll continue to raise my fist
And hide my mother's cries
They may shoot you with their words
Cut me up with their swords
They may insult you with their eyes
Denigrate me with their lies
Trying to kill you with their hate
Bury me alive to seal my fate
But they'd certainly
Be shamed and fail
As the free chant and sing
On their march to prevail
So keep your head held high
As I follow you and try
And keep your beautiful smile
As I walk my first mile
They'll pressure and blame
Throw us in prison to control and tame
They'll exile and defame
Lynch us all or shoot and maim
Burn crosses with no shame
Target our children in a dirty game
But why is that a surprise?
Despite their evil and terror
Their falsehood and lies
You shall rise
And I shall rise
You're the black ocean
Leaping and wide
I'm the Mediterranean
With a stormy tide
Staying together
Side by side
It's no surprise
We shall rise
Surely shall rise
We together shall rise
No Longer Afraid
For us to feel "secure"
What price is being paid?
If living in freedom
Why are we afraid?
Fear is everywhere
All around
Perhaps irrational
But without any bound
You can see it on our faces
Sense it in our eyes
You can hear it in our whispers
Feel it in our cries
More>>No Longer Afraid
The Bird and The Vulture
The bird was chirping
In a house on a tree
But the vulture was angry
Because it was free
When the bird is singing
The vulture ain't safe
More>>The Bird and The Vulture
The Smile of Freedom
He looked like
A body-builder
Tall, tough, and full
All muscles and no fat
His mind was simple
Suited to follow orders
No questions asked
Acting mean and mechanical
Like any bureaucrat
More>>The Smile ...
In the Name of Freedom
In the name of freedom
We shall rule the world
To spread democracy
And set you free
In the name of freedom
We’ll descend on you
To make you civilized
Modern and orderly
More>>In the Name ...
The Accused: Franz Kafka Meets George Orwell in 21st Century America
Act I: The Mother of all Evidence
Act II- Weapons of Mass Deception
Act III: Silencing of the Lambs
Act IV: Attacks of the Wolves
Act V: Occupied Territory
Act VI: Police State
Act VII: Official Obituary
Act VIII: A Close Encounter of the Scariest Kind
Act IX: The Inquisition
Act X- Conspiracy Theory
Act XI- Secret Trials
Act XII- Silent Pain and Teary Eyes
Act XIII- True Patriot Acts
Do Not Sign
Rights are not for sale
History is not kind
On those who sell their people out,
Betray their cause,
Surrender their land
To tow the line
Do not sign
More>>Do Not Sign
Rachel Corrie: Daughter of Palestine
The most gentle
Amongst all honorable
Had a spirit
As dazzling as
The garden of
More>>Daughter of Palestine
Ole Jerusalem
O Ole Jerusalem
I feel your pain
I hear your cries
The light thunder
In the darkness
And the heavy rain
I see the steady bleeding
Of your wound
With its mark and stain
More>>Ole Jerusalem
Patrick Henry
A revolutionary
At heart
A patriot
From the start
Loved by his country
To the core
Defended freedom
Even more
Hated arrogance
In shape and tone
Fought tyranny
With every bone
He was the conscience
Of his people
Striking fear in the enemy
And made it feeble
More>> Patrick Henry
An overwhelming feeling
Of bitterness
Of hatred and rage
Trapped in a cage
Disappointment and anger
Continuing to linger
Wounding of dignity
Violating your virginity
More>> Injustice
Political Riddles
He sees the world as black and white
His solution to every quandary is fight with might
The economy will not stimulate
Because he can’t articulate
While jobs are gone
He says, “bring ‘em on.”
Who is he?
He likes to be called the General
The head of an agency that’s federal
If you spit on the sidewalk
He’ll send the Incredible Hulk
He hates to cite truth or fact
Because he’s busy promoting his unpatriotic act
He frequents TV cameras with a smash
The first part of his last name sounds like trash
Who is he?
He is the ideal dutiful poodle they say
From an empire where the sun did not set one day
He adores his cowboy friend and considers him a fan
And insists: I’m nobody’s yes-man
When the cowboy says no, I say no
Who is he?
More>>Political Riddles